In an interview with Gamespot (ta, PCGamesN), Fallout 4 creative director Todd Howard spoke about what he considers to be that game's successes and failures. Like a lot of people, myself and Andrew Kelly included, Howard doesn't think the new dialogue system worked out all that well, but he's positive about Fallout 4's expanded combat.
"We do like to try new things and we have some successes. I think the shooting in Fallout 4 is really good I think it plays really well. Obviously the way we did some dialogue stuff, that didn't work as well. But I know the reasons we tried that to make a nice interactive conversation but [it was] less successful than some other things in the game. For us, we take that feedback. I think long-term."
Many people took issue with the new, streamlined dialogue system, leading to a mod that replaced it with a hard list of the things the player character was actually going to say. While the dialogue wheel wasn't removed for Fallout 4 expansion Far Harbour, from what I hear the DLC did offer more choice, more ways to resolve things without resorting to violence.
"Then we have an opportunity with something like Far Harbor," Howard continues, talking about learning from feedback. "Like: okay, how many different ways can it end let's give them some more choice. So it's not just a one-off, meaning Fallout 4 comes out and then we forget about it it's an ongoing thing. The feedback we get is really, really helpful."
I'm hopeful this means we won't see a similar dialogue system in The Elder Scrolls VI, which is a thing that is obviously in development.
